Book Review – The Perfect Circle by Claudia Petrucci, translated by Anne Milano Appel @WorldEdBooks

About the Book

In the round house on Via Saterna, its Palladian square exterior nothing but a trompe-l’oeil, the sun pierces through the central skylight. Its rays pass three floors unobstructed, before reaching the circle below at the heart of the house: four fingers of water filling a little silver basin. It is here that young Lidia dies, setting an end to her clandestine love affair with the ambitious architect.

It is this house that real-estate agent Irene is asked to sell, decades later, as the climate catastrophe escalates, cloaking the divided city in a permanent orange haze. Returning to her native Milan for the sale, Irene feels the brunt of her father’s judgement. He is a proud Italian and prouder architect—how could his own daughter make a living selling cultural patrimony to the highest foreign bidder?

As she faces this new Milan and the old family tensions she had avoided while living in Rome, Irene throws herself into the impossible sale, getting to know Via Saterna intimately—this space that is as unsettling as it is hostile, with the slowly emerging traces of Lidia’s interrupted life. In every room of the house, the burden of a mysterious, unresolved past can be felt, remnants of a selfish and manipulative love.

Format: Paperback (242 pages) Publisher: World Editions
Publication date: 7th April 2026 Genre: Fiction

Find The Perfect Circle on Goodreads

Purchase The Perfect Circle from Bookshop.org [Disclosure: If you buy books linked to our site, we may earn a commission from Bookshop.org, whose fees support independent bookshops]

My Review

The book alternates between two timelines – one set in the near future and the other in the 1980s – which progress in opposite directions chronologically.

In the storyline set in the near future, Milan is a city shrouded in dense fog, the result of climate change. There is social unrest prompting calls from some for construction of a wall to separate the crime-ridden parts of the city from the rest. All this gives an unsettling feel to the book, a suitable backdrop as it turns out to events in the house on Via Saterna. Irene has been commissioned to sell the house at auction by a lawyer named Ferrari. A specialist in selling heritage properties to wealthy investors, Irene is confident she can get a good price even given its unusual design. Ferrari is not so sure about its arcihtectural merits, adding ‘I would venture a certain amount of bad luck looms over this property.’

Irene sets about researching the history of the house and making an inventory of its contents. What she comes across both surprises and alarms her. And there are things that just don’t make sense. As she spends more time in the house, it starts to exert a strange pull on her.

The second storyline unfolds in reverse chronological order, gradually revealing the events that led up to the death in 1986 of Lidia, the young woman who once owned the house and commissioned its ambitious redesign. As the reader discovers, it’s a tragedy born out of a betrayal whose consequences will be played out in a most unexpected way decades later.

There are very many clever touches such as the fact the design of the house on Via Saterna is centred around a skylight through which the sun illuminates a silver basin filled with water at certain points of the day, whereas Milan is now shrouded in fog so dense that sunlight rarely penetrates it.

The Perfect Circle is a very cleverly plotted story with an ending that reflects the book’s title in a most satisfying way.

I received a review copy courtesy of World Editions via NetGalley.

In three words: Intriguing, atmospheric, assured

About the Author

Claudia Petrucci studied Modern Letters in Milan before moving to Perth, Australia. Her reportages and short stories—which range from realistic to weird to science fiction—have been published on Cadillacminima&moralia, and elsewhere. 

The Performance is her debut novel. It was shortlisted for the John Fante Award and won the prestigious Premio Flaiano Giovani, for writers under 30. It was also book of the day on Fahrenheit, an Italian radio program, and it has been translated into German and French. The Perfect Circle is her second novel to be translated into English. (Photo/bio: Publisher author page)

Connect with Claudia
Website | Instagram | Facebook | X

About the Translator

Anne Milano Appel is a translator and a former library administrator, and she has a doctorate in Romance languages. She has translated works by a number of leading Italian authors, including the award-winning Antonio Scurati and Paolo Maurensig. Her awards include the Italian Prose in Translation Award, the John Florio Prize for Italian Translation, and the Northern California Book Award for Translation. 

Book Review – The Prisoner of Zenda by Anthony Hope @ourclassicsclub #ccspin

About the Book

English gentleman Rudolph Rassendyll bears a striking resemblance to Rudolf Elphberg who is about to be crowned King of Ruritania. When the rival to the throne, Black Michael of Strelsau, attempts to seize power by imprisoning Elphberg in the Castle of Zenda, Rassendyll is obliged to impersonate the King to uphold the rightful sovereignty and ensure political stability.

Rassendyll endures a trial of strength in his encounters with the notorious Rupert of Hentzau, and a test of a different sort as he grows to love the Princess Flavia.

Format: Audiobook (5h 31m) Publisher: Audible
Publication date: 24th August 2008 [1894] Genre: Classics

Find The Prisoner of Zenda on Goodreads

My Review

The Prisoner of Zenda was the book chosen for me in the latest Classics Club Spin. First published in 1894, the book has been filmed five times. The Prisoner of Zenda is set in the fictional country of Ruritania, located somewhere in Central Europe. It actually spawned a genre, the ‘Ruritanian romance’, inspiring many similar books.

English gentleman Rudolf Rassendyll, distantly related to the ruling house of Ruritania, and having nothing better to occupy himself with, travels from London to witness Rudolf Elphberg being crowned King of Ruritania. Rassendyll bears an uncanny resemblence to the King, notably his shock of red hair, and when the King is drugged and kidnapped by his brother, the Duke of Strelsau (known by the soubriquet ‘Black Michael’), Rassendyll takes the King’s place. He carries it off with aplomb, no-one noticing the swap, not even the Princess Flavia whom the King has been expected to wed. Black Michael of course knows about the deception but cannot reveal it without exposing himself as the kidnapper of the King.

Despite his best efforts, Rassendyll falls in love with Princess Flavia but there is a rival for her affections – Black Michael. When Michael’s mistress learns of this, she reveals to Rassendyll the location where the King is being kept prisoner – the Castle of Zenda. Rassendyll and his compatriots embark on a mission to free the King from the seemingly impregnable castle. To do this they must overcome ‘The Six’, highly skilled mercenaries employed by Black Michael. One of these is the dashing Rupert of Henzau, the subject of the book’s sequel.

The Prisoner of Zenda is an enjoyably swashbuckling adventure. It’s a story in which the women are beautiful, the villains are dastardly and there are narrow escapes galore. I was reminded of John Buchan’s description of what he referred to as his ‘shockers’, such as The Thirty-Nine Steps, as tales ‘where the incidents defy the probabilities, and march just inside the borders of the possible’.

As it happens Buchan wrote his own homage to The Prisoner of Zenda, his 1935 novel The House of the Four Winds, set in the fictional country of Evallonia. Ursula Buchan, Buchan’s granddaughter and biographer, described it as ‘probably JB’s worst novel’ and as ‘Ruritania without the charm’. I’m afraid I felt much the same when I read it.

I listened to the audiobook version ably narrated by James Wilby.

About the Author

Sir Anthony Hope Hawkins was born in 1863 and was a prolific writer of adventure novels although he is best known for The Prisoner of Zenda (1894) and its sequel Rupert of Henzau (1898).

Hope trained as a lawyer and barrister but eventually turned to writing. His short pieces appeared in periodicals but he was forced to self-publish his first novel. It is said the idea for The Prisoner of Zenda came to him whilst walking in London, completing the first draft in just a month.

Hope wrote and co-wrote many plays and political non-fiction during the First World War, some for the Ministry of Information. He died in 1933.