Book Review – normal rules don’t apply by Kate Atkinson

About the Book

Book cover of normal rules don't apply by Kate Atkinson

In this first full collection since Not the End of the World, we meet a queen who makes a bargain she cannot keep; a secretary who watches over the life she has just left; a man whose luck changes when a horse speaks to him.

With clockwork intricacy, inventiveness and sharp social observation, Kate Atkinson conjures a feast for the imagination, a constantly changing multiverse in which nothing is quite as it seems . . .

Format: Paperback (240 pages) Publisher: Penguin
Publication date: 23rd May 2024 Genre: Short Stories

Find normal rules don’t apply on Goodreads

Purchase normal rules don’t apply from Bookshop.org [Disclosure: If you buy books linked to our site, we may earn a commission from Bookshop.org, whose fees support independent bookshops]


My Review

This was a book club pick and almost without exception members enjoyed this engaging collection of short stories. For many, this was their first time reading Kate Atkinson’s work.

From the very first story the reader is immersed in a world where unpredictable things happen but often in the most everyday of situations, such as in a Waitrose supermarket in the opening story, ‘The Void’. Even when you’re dead, as in ‘Blithe Spirits’, it turns out there are rules of time and place you might not expect.

I loved the interconnections between the stories some of which are so ‘under the radar’ you might only pick up on them on a second reading. My favourite involved an 18th century patterned wallpaper. One character, Franklin, appears in a number of stories although his life does not necessarily follow a linear pattern, alluding to the final story, ‘What If?’.

One of my favourite stories was ‘Spellbound’ in which a fairy tale is combined with a depiction of the stresses and strains of contemporary family life, and whose last line filled me with delight at its cleverness. There are some memorable characters, such as the eponymous heroine of ‘Shine, Pamela! Shine!’ who the author manages to make both a figure of fun and someone for whom you have sympathy. The only story I didn’t care for was ‘Existential Marginalization’ but only because I found it genuinely creepy. However, other book club members who don’t mind dark aspects to a story loved it.

As well as all the clever interconnections, there are some recurring themes including motherhood and the environment. The latter is most obvious in the story ‘Gene-sis’ (superbly clever title given what unfolds) in which the damage humans wreak on the planet is seemingly beyond even the Creator to prevent.

normal rules don’t apply (including of punctuation) is a really enjoyable collection of short stories whose myriad interconnections means it’s best read as one continuous whole rather than dipping in and out of individual stories. And it’s a book that would definitely repay rereading to pick up all the little connections between stories you missed first time around.

In three words: Playful, inventive, entertaining
Try something similar: In This Ravishing World by Nina Schuyler


About the Author

Author Kate Atkinson

Kate Atkinson is one of the world’s foremost novelists. Her most recent novel, Shrines of Gaiety, set in the aftermath of the First World War, is a Sunday Times bestseller. She won the Whitbread Book of the Year prize with her first novel, Behind the Scenes at the Museum.

Her three critically lauded and prize-winning novels set around the Second World War are Life After Life, an acclaimed 2022 BBC TV series, A God in Ruins (both winners of the Costa Novel Award) and Transcription. Her bestselling literary crime novels featuring former detective Jackson Brodie, Case Histories, One Good Turn, When Will There Be Good News? and Started Early, Took My Dog, became a BBC TV series starring Jason Isaacs. Jackson Brodie later returned in the novel Big Sky.

Kate Atkinson was awarded an MBE in 2011 and is a Fellow of the Royal Society of Literature.

Book Review – The Housekeepers by Alex Hay

About the Book

Book cover of The Housekeepers by Alex Hay

UPSTAIRS, MADAM IS PLANNING THE PARTY OF THE SEASON.

All eyes are on the grandest house in Mayfair as the countdown to their lavish summer ball begins. Everything must be perfect. But with the chandeliers gleaming and the cellars stocked, loyal housekeeper Mrs King is suddenly dismissed.

DOWNSTAIRS, THE SERVANTS ARE PLOTTING THE HEIST OF THE CENTURY.

As the clock strikes twelve on the night of the ball, Mrs King will return to strip the house of its riches – right under the nose of her former employer. And she knows just who to recruit to pull off the impossible: a bold alliance of women with nothing left to lose and every reason for revenge.

Format: ebook (365 pages) Publisher: Headline
Publication date: 6th July 2023 Genre: Historical Fiction, Crime

Find The Housekeepers on Goodreads

Purchase The Housekeepers from Bookshop.org [Disclosure: If you buy books linked to our site, we may earn a commission from Bookshop.org, whose fees support independent bookshops]


My Review

This was a book club pick by members wanting something lighthearted after a series of rather serious books such as last month’s choice, The Zone of Interest by Martin Amis.

‘Imagine it, ladies: the grandest house in London, licked clean on the biggest night of the season.’

I liked the idea of a group of women coming together to plan an audacious heist, a female equivalent if you like of the group of men in the 1960 film The League of Gentleman in which the involuntarily-retired Lieutenant Colonel Hyde (played by Jack Hawkins) recruits seven other dissatisfied ex-servicemen to commit a bank robbery. Although the women who christen themselves ‘The Housekeepers’ each have slightly different reasons for wanting to take part, the underlying motivation is revenge but other motivations become apparent as the book progresses. As a result, the operation turns into a desire to obtain justice for others as much as for themselves.

I found the book entertaining although a bit on the slow side as the heist doesn’t actually take place until nearly two thirds of the way through the book, at which point it all becomes rather frenzied and a little confused. I found the mechanics of the heist (involving the use of rope swings, winches and extendable poles amongst other things) stretched credulity, although perhaps it was the author’s intention to introduce an element of outrageous absurdity to the proceedings. The secret of what has been going on in the de Vries household didn’t come as much of a surprise although it did provide some vindication for the women’s actions. The relationship between sewing maid Alice with her mistress Miss de Vries introduces what has become a familiar trope in historical fiction.

My favourite character was Hephzibah Grandcourt whose gift for acting produces some very amusing scenes and whose sheer chutzpah proves vital to the mission when it encounters some sticky moments. I also liked Mrs Bone, a woman who has built a criminal enterprise to rival – if not outdo – her male counterparts.

To steal an observation by one of my fellow book club members, The Housekeepers ‘does what is says on the tin’. It’s an entertaining book that doesn’t take itself too seriously but sets itself apart from the current wave of ‘cosy crime’ novels by focussing on those carrying out the crime rather than those solving it. (Readers may also want to note there is a bonus chapter in the paperback edition which is not in the ebook. The audiobook version was also highly praised by book club members.)

In three words: Engaging, undemanding, humorous
Try something similar: The Great Train Robbery by Michael Crichton


About the Author

Author Alex Hay

Alex grew up in Cambridge and Cardiff in the United Kingdom. He studied History at the University of York and wrote his dissertation on female power at royal courts, combing the archives for every scrap of drama and skulduggery he could find. He has worked in magazine publishing and the charity sector and lives with his husband in London. His debut novel, The Housekeepers, won the Caledonia Novel Award 2022 and was published to great critical acclaim. (Photo: Amazon author page)

Connect with Alex
X | Instagram