Throwback Thursday: A Countess in Limbo by Olga Hendrikoff & Sue Carscallen

ThrowbackThursday

Throwback Thursday is a weekly meme originally created by Renee at It’s Book Talk.  It’s designed as an opportunity to share old favourites as well as books that we’ve finally got around to reading that were published over a year ago.

I recently took part in the blog tour for A Romanov Empress by C. W. Gortner, the fictionalised story of the life of Maria Feodorovna, mother of Nicholas II, the last Tsar of Russia.    Whilst reading the book, it reminded me of a fascinating memoir I read in 2017 by a woman who lived through some of that turbulent period in Russian history.  Called A Countess in Limbo: Diaries in War & Revolution, it recounts the experiences of Countess Olga “Lala” Hendrikoff based on her personal journals collected and translated by her great niece, Sue Carscallen.  To read a wonderful interview with Sue about her memories of Olga and the process of writing the book, click here.

A Countess in Limbo was published in November 2016 by Archway Publishing and you can find purchase links below.


CountessAbout the Book

Countess Olga “Lala” Hendrikoff was born into the Russian aristocracy, serving as lady-in-waiting to the empresses and enjoying a life of great privilege. But on the eve of her wedding in 1914 came the first rumours of an impending war – a war that would change her life forever and force her to flee her country as a stateless person with no country to call home.  Spanning two of the most turbulent times in modern history—World War I in Russia and World War II in Paris – Countess Hendrikoff’s journals demonstrate the uncertainty, horror, and hope of daily life in the midst of turmoil. Her razor-sharp insight, wit, and sense of humour create a fascinating eyewitness account of the Russian Revolution and the occupation and liberation of Paris.

Format: ebook (337 pp.)                           Publisher: Archway Publishing
Published: 3rd November 2016             Genre: Memoir, History, Non-Fiction

Purchase Links*
Amazon.co.uk  ǀ  Amazon.com
*links provided for convenience, not as part of any affiliate programme

Find A Countess in Limbo on Goodreads


My Review

I found these journals absolutely fascinating and I was amazed how a woman could live through such upheaval, struggle, loss and privation and still provide such an objective commentary on events, managing to see the good – and bad – on both sides.

In the first section, the young Olga recounts some of her experiences living in Russia at the outbreak of World War I.  There are touching scenes, such as when she and her mother witness the departure of her younger brother to join the army. ‘To the strains of martial music, the train, illuminated by the last rays of the setting sun, started pulling away from the platform and soon vanished in the evening darkness.  With long-repressed tears flowing without measure, my mother and I stood on the platform for a few more minutes.’

Olga did not keep journals throughout her life – or at least, none remain – so there are gaps where only her great niece’s research can try to provide welcome answers.  One such mystery is the circumstances around the ending of her marriage after only three years.

The sections of the book containing the journals Olga Hendrikoff kept during World War 2, covering the onset of war, the occupation of France and its liberation, I found particularly compelling.  Throughout there is a sense of incredulity that nations should so quickly repeat the mistakes of history.  ‘Another war with Germany seems incredible to me when no-one has yet forgotten the last one.’  Later she observes: ‘I often wake up in the morning thinking I have had a bad dream – the war, the departure of friends and relatives…  The first few days after the war was declared, it was if I was stunned.  I could not bring myself to believe that the country I live in is really at war.’

Olga documents the daily struggle to find food, fuel to keep warm and employment so that items only available on the thriving black market can be purchased.  She vividly describes how the German advance into France provokes the desperate flight of people.  ‘The route nationale is still clogged with refugees who make use of any means of locomotion: men on bicycles, women on foot pushing baby carriages, babies in wheelbarrows pulled like trailers by bicycles, mule- or horse-drawn carriages, strollers…in a word, anything on wheels, anything that rolls, has been mobilised for the exodus.’

The liberation of Paris brings no end to the food shortages, power cuts and daily struggle.  It also brings something worse – reprisals against those deemed to have been collaborators.  ‘In the troubled times we are going through, alas, the spirit of personal vengeance is naturally given free rein.’

Olga becomes one of hundreds of thousands stateless émigrés, in her case unable to return to Russia following the revolution and its transformation into the Soviet Union.   However, she never loses her affection for her homeland, which she looks back on fondly.  ‘Would it suddenly be possible to go back to your own country and see Russian forests again, the rivers you knew as a child, the landscapes you still hold in your heart?’ In the end, economic pressures force her to leave France and, since a return to Russia is impossible, she embarks for America where she spent the remainder of her long life.

Countess Hendrikoff was clearly a remarkable woman with wit, intelligence, resilience, compassion for others and a relentless determination to survive.  It is wonderful that her journals survive in order that modern readers can share her experiences and her admirable outlook on life.  There is so much more that I could mention about this book but I will simply urge you to read it for yourself.  One final quotation, should you need more persuading: ‘All war seems absurd to me anyway.  The victors often lose in the exchange, and the vanquished think only of revenge.’

I received a review copy courtesy of the author and publishers, Archway Publishing, in return for an honest review.

In three words: Enthralling, moving, inspirational

Try something similar… The Romanov Empress by C. W. Gortner (read my review here)

Follow my blog with Bloglovin


CarscallenAbout the Authors

Olga Hendrikoff was born in 1892 in Voronezh, Russia, and attended the famous Smolny Institute. In 1914, she married Count Peter Hendrikoff just as World War I began.  In the ensuing years, Hendrikoff lived in Constantinople, Rome, Paris, and Philadelphia. She spent her last 20 years in Calgary. She died in 1987.

Sue Carscallen spent 20 years with Olga Hendrikoff before her great aunt’s passing in 1987.  Carscallen stumbled upon Hendrikoff’s diaries hidden in a trunk at her great aunt’s Calgary home.  Over time she unraveled the mysteries hidden in the manuscripts, travelling to France and Russia to supplement her research into Hendrikoff’s life.  Today, Carscallen resides in Calgary.

Website | Facebook ǀ  Goodreads

Throwback Thursday: The Last Train by Michael Pronko

ThrowbackThursday

Throwback Thursday is a weekly meme originally created by Renee at It’s Book Talk.  It’s designed as an opportunity to share old favourites as well as books that we’ve finally got around to reading that were published over a year ago.

Today I’m revisiting a book I reviewed in December 2017 but which had been on my author review pile for quite a long while before that – The Last Train by Michael Pronko – the first in the author’s Detective Hiroshi series set in Tokyo.  The Last Train was published in May 2017 and you can find purchase links below.  It is also now available as an audiobook.

The Moving BladeAs you will see from my review below, I really enjoyed The Last Train so I was thrilled to learn from the author’s July newsletter that the next book in the series, The Moving Blade, is due out on 10th September 2018.  Find out more about it here.


TheLastTrainAbout the Book

Detective Hiroshi Shimizu investigates white collar crime in Tokyo. He’s lost his girlfriend and still dreams of his time studying in America, but with a stable job, his own office and a half-empty apartment, he’s settled in.   When an American businessman turns up dead, his mentor Takamatsu calls him out to the site of a grisly murder. A glimpse from a security camera video suggests the killer was a woman, but in Japan, that seems unlikely. Hiroshi quickly learns how close homicide and suicide can appear in a city full of high-speed trains just a step – or a push – away. Takamatsu drags Hiroshi out to the hostess clubs and skyscraper offices of Tokyo in search of the killer. To find her, Hiroshi goes deeper and deeper into Tokyo’s intricate, ominous market for buying and selling the most expensive land in the world. Hiroshi’s determined to cut through Japan’s ambiguities – and dangers – to find the murdering ex-hostess before she extracts her final revenge – which just might be him.

Format: Audiobook/ebook, paperback (348 pp.) Publisher: Raked Gravel Press
Published: 5th May 2017                                          Genre: Crime, Thriller

Purchase Links*
Amazon.co.uk  ǀ  Amazon.com
*links provided for convenience, not as part of any affiliate programme

Find The Last Train on Goodreads


My Review

When I interviewed Michael on my blog last year (click here to read the full interview), he described The Last Train as ‘more whydunit than whodunit’ and having now read the book I can certainly understood why he said that.  Much of the excitement of the book comes from following detective Hiroshi Suzuki in his attempts to identify and track down the woman who committed the murderer.  The trail leads him from the flashy malls and smart high-rise buildings to the decidedly seedier world of hostess clubs and bars.  As the author explains, “…in the novel, I wanted to look beneath the surface. The giant skyscrapers and constant construction are amazing, but there’s a lot going on behind the go-go big-city bright-lights, and a lot of it not so good.”

As the investigation progresses, Hiroshi begins to understand the threat he faces from vested interests who may be involved in the shady dealings he starts to uncover.  He also starts to realise just what a clever and ruthless opponent he is up against and to get an inkling into the motivation that drives her.  When the full facts are revealed you may find yourself questioning where true justice lies.

What really set The Last Train apart from other run-of-the-mill crime thrillers for me was its Tokyo setting.  I loved learning all about Japanese culture and customs.  Take this scene in which Hiroshi and his boss, Takamatsu, drink sake together in the traditional manner.

‘The master pulled back a brown curtain over a glass-sided refrigerator filled with sake bottles.  He pulled out two small chilled glasses from the top shelf and set these on the upper counter inside small, square, cedar wood boxes.  The master shuffled the dozen or so bottles inside the fridge until he found the ones he wanted.  Carrying these to the counter, he hoisted the large bottle of cold sake and, cradling it in the crook of his arm, poured out the clear, clean liquid.  The sake flowed gently over the top of the lip of the glass into the box, arousing the aroma of cedar and fresh rice.  He poured out sake from a different bottle for Hiroshi and placed both bottles on the counter so that each displayed the artful calligraphy of their labels.

They bowed down like penitents to take the first sip without spilling.  Then they plucked up the small, thumb-sized glasses for a silent toast before downing the second gulp.  Finally, they poured the spill-over from the cedar box into the glass, took another sip, and set their half-full glasses back inside the wet cedar boxes.’

The book cleverly brings to life the intriguing juxtaposition of ancient and modern that exists in Japan.  So you have the temples and prayer rituals, the elaborate customs for greeting and drinking tea.  But at the same time you have the flashy malls full of shops selling designer goods and the latest technology and the packed subways and sidewalks of Roppongi.

‘People streamed out of subway exits, slid out of taxis, and stepped off bus after bus.  Hordes of office workers in dull gray pants and dark skirts blocked corners, shouting directions into their cell phones to those yet to arrive.  Fashion-conscious hipsters, mini-skirted amateurs, and yakuza wannabes walked to their favourite places to play, eat, drink, or work.’

The work culture with its emphasis on drinking with colleagues after work, to my eyes at least, seems particularly alien and the position of women quite regressive with real antipathy in some quarters towards women whose behaviour is seen as ‘un-Japanese’.

I really enjoyed The Last Train for both its compelling storyline and its use of Tokyo as a location.  Luckily for me – and I suspect, other readers – the author is working on two further books in the series, both of which are due for publication in 2018.

In three words: Atmospheric, compelling, mystery

Try something similar… Wolves in the Dark by Gunnar Staalesen (click here to read my review)

Follow my blog with Bloglovin


MichaelPronkoAbout the Author

Michael Pronko is a professor of American Literature and Culture at Meiji Gakuin University in Tokyo and writes about Japanese culture, art, jazz, and politics for Newsweek Japan, The Japan Times, Artscape Japan and other publications.  He has appeared on NHK Public TV, Tokyo MXTV and Nippon Television.  His website, Jazz in Japan can be found at www.jazzinjapan.com.  His award-winning collections of essays about life in Tokyo are: Beauty and Chaos: Slices and Morsels of Tokyo Life (2014), Tokyo’s Mystery Deepens: Essays on Tokyo (2014), and Motions and Moments: More Essays on Tokyo (2015). He has also published three essay collections in Japanese.  When not teaching or writing, he wanders Tokyo contemplating its intensity and waiting for the stories to come.

Connect with Michael

Website  ǀ  Facebook ǀ  Twitter  ǀ  Goodreads