Book Review – The Sea Road West by Sally Rena #NOVNOV25

About the Book

The road from the Scottish mainland to Kintillo lies across a ridge of craggy and forbidding hills, a natural barrier isolating the peninsular from the rest of the world and making Kintillo a place of both refuge and solitude. But trouble begins when Father Macabe dies, and Father James, a new, young man arrives.

Handsome and full of ideals, Father James is totally unprepared for the spell-binding beauty of the lonely country, and for the irrelevance of his philanthropic fervour to the lives of its inhabitants. For company, there is only a retired doctor, a charming and alcoholic wreck, and the inhabitants of the Hall – the Laird and his two pretty daughters.

Meriel Finlay is one of these daughters – a captivating 19 year old yearning for love and adventure. As mutual desire slowly ripens, can Father James continue to keep focus on his profession when it denies him his basic instincts?

Passions hidden below the surface, maturing in loneliness, erupt in a violent upsurge of love, hatred and jealousy which sweep through Kintillo like a storm…

Format: ebook (176 pages) Publisher: Endeavour Press
Publication date: 30th November 2014 [1975] Genre: Fiction

Find The Sea Road West on Goodreads

My Review

I came across this book when searching on my Kindle for short novels to read for Novellas in November, hosted by Cathy at 746 Books and Rebecca at Bookish Beck. As I started reading it a lot seemed familiar which means I’ve either read something very much like it or I’ve actually read it before. I think it might be the latter.

The blurb tells you pretty much all you need to know about the story but doesn’t give a sense of the simmering emotional and sexual tension that pervades the book.

Father James comes to Kintillo hoping to make a difference to the lives of its residents but finds them frustratingly unreponsive to his efforts. They prefer to live their lives the same way they always have, resisting change even although this is ultimately inevitable. Morag, the rectory housekeeper, was devoted to the late Father Macabe and resents the arrival of Father James finding, initially, petty ways to show it. Charles Finlay, son of the ageing Laird, rarely mixes with the villagers and is emotionally distant from his two daughters – Anne and Meriel. He finds comfort in a monotonous daily routine which, one suspects, is a way of restraining more violent instincts within. ‘Such a rage overwhelmed him that it was almost voluptuous.’

On the other hand, the free-spirited Meriel Finlay yearns for change of some sort. However as she admits, ‘The trouble is I don’t know what I want.’ The arrival of Father James conveniently offers an outlet for that frustration. Meriel is aware of her sexual attractiveness but unmindful of its effect on others and perhaps careless of the consequences of her actions. Father James finds himself unable to resist her youthful energy despite knowing a sexual relationship conflicts with his priestly vows. In pursuing a relationship with Father James, Meriel is the catalyst for events which build to an explosive and rather unexpected climax.

I enjoyed the wonderful descriptions of the Scottish landscape and the way the author evokes life in a small village in which it’s difficult for anything to remain hidden for long. But the ending I wasn’t so sure about. It left me with more questions than answers, although perhaps that was the author’s intention.

The Sea Road West was first published in 1975 and does not appear to be currently available to purchase.

In three words: Atmospheric, intense, dramatic

About the Author

Sally Rena was born in Scotland and lived there until the age of sixteen. She is convent educated and spent two years of further education in France and Italy. She is married with four children.

My Year in Novellas #NovNov25

Novellas in November 2025

Novellas in November is an annual reading event hosted by Cathy at 746 Books and Rebecca at Bookish Beck designed to celebrate the art of the short book. When it comes to what classifies as a novella, our hosts suggest books should be less than 200 pages, and ideally under 150 pages. There are also two buddy reads including one of the books – Seascraper by Benjamin Wood – on my reading list.

We’re invited to begin the event by posting a review of the novellas we’ve read in the past twelve months. I was a bit disappointed to find so few novellas – four to be precise – amongst the list of books I’ve read since 1st December 2024. They’re listed below with links to my reviews.

For thy great pain have mercy on my little pain by Victoria MacKenzie – In the year of 1413, two female mystics – Margery Kempe and Julian of Norwich – meet for the first time in the city of Norwich.

Queen Macbeth by Val McDermid – Exploring the truth behind the story of the woman we know as Lady Macbeth in Shakespeare;s play but whose real name was Gruoch and herself possessed royal blood.

Woman in Blue by Douglas Bruton – Each day a man visits the Rijksmuseum to gaze at the painting Woman in Blue Reading a Letter by Vermeer. Only that painting, and for hours on end. 

Orbital by Samantha Harvey – Six astronauts rotate in their spacecraft above the earth. Together they watch our silent blue planet: endless shows of spectacular beauty witnessed in a single day.

I’ve scoured my shelves and my Kindle for any novellas I’ve not yet read and have come up with four, including one conveniently recently sent to me by the author.

Seascraper by Benjamin Wood – ‘A mesmerising portrait of a young man confined in by his class and the ghosts of his family’s past, dreaming of artistic fulfilment.’

Benbecula by Graeme Macrae Burnet – ‘A dark, psychological thriller, leavened by moments of black humour and absurdity.’

The Forgotten Daughter by Anirudh Joshi – ‘In the rain-slick alleys of Kamathipura, truth is a luxury few can afford. When Meher disappears, the city shrugs—but one man refuses to forget.’

The Shooting Party by Isobel Colegate – ‘A quiet, elegant meditation on class frustration and the transience of human concern.’