Book Review – The Endeavour of Elsie Mackay by Flora Johnston @AllisonandBusby

About the Book

Front cover of The Endeavour of Elsie Mackay by Flora Johnsotn featuring woman in flying gear

1927. Flight fever is running rampant and daring flyers are all anyone can talk about. And now the Honourable Miss Elsie Mackay, glamorous former film star and regular name in gossip columns, has a new ambition – to be the first woman to fly the Atlantic.

Stella Campbell was once at the heart of world events, working at the Paris Peace Conference she helped forge peace across Europe. Now a decade on, post-war hopes are frayed and marriage and motherhood have worn away Stella’s sense of self until she’s not sure what remains.

In recent years, Stella’s sister Corran has been wrapped up in her books and academic career, determinedly single, or so it seems. But when carefully guarded secrets start to emerge, will she be able to step beyond the constraints of her sex?

Three women, a fearless aviatrix, a jaded wife and a secretive academic strain to reach for their dreams on the cusp of an uncertain future.

Format: Hardcover (352 pages) Publisher: Allison & Busby
Publication date: 23rd January 2025 Genre: Historical Fiction

Find The Endeavour of Elsie Mackay on Goodreads

Purchase The Endeavour of Elsie Mackay from Bookshop.org [


My Review

I didn’t realise until I started reading the book that The Endeavour of Elsie Mackay, as well as being a fictionalised account of the exploits of a real life pioneering female aviator, continues the stories of many of the characters who feature in the author’s previous book, The Paris Peacemakers. That wasn’t a problem for me because I loved The Paris Peacemakers. In fact it was an unexpected bonus to be able to find out what had happened to them in the years between the two books. There are brief recaps of events in The Paris Peacemakers that would enable you to enjoy The Endeavour of Elsie Mackay even if you haven’t read the earlier book.

Although Elsie’s ‘endeavour’ (the nature of which we know from the start) is not the only focus of the book, it is the most compelling. Elsie is a wonderfully flamboyant character. She’s a regular guest at glamorous parties dressed in the latest fashions, and rubbing shoulders with the rich and famous. But she’s also a woman who relishes time at her family’s Scottish home, Glenapp Castle, enjoying the countryside or picknicking on the beach. But she’s frustrated at the unwillingness of her father, Lord Inchcape, to let her become more involved in his business, the P&O shipping line. Although she is allowed to use her talent for interior design, she longs to have the responsibilties she feels she would have had if she had been a son rather than a daughter.

Although we know what Elsie’s dream is from the start, the interest comes from seeing how she goes about overcoming the considerable obstacles that stand in the way of her achieving it . She does this with a mixture of charm, the occasional deception and sheer persistence. And she’s not averse to using her father’s influence on occasions. But achieving her dream isn’t just about becoming the first woman to fly the Atlantic, she also believes it will prove civil aviation is the way of the future. Above all flying gives her a sense of freedom, a sense of meaning even, that she can’t find anywhere else.

Although the First World War is over, its impact is still apparent whether that’s the physical or mental scars people bear, the empty chairs at a table or the struggle to return to normal life. In fact, frustration with where you have ended up is something many of the characters share.

Stella, having played an important role in the Paris Peace Conference, finds herself living with her husband Rob and their two children in a small Glasgow tenement along with her widowed mother, Alison. It’s cramped – there’s not enough space for a separate bedroom for herself and Rob – and the daily grind of household chores and caring for her children has left her feeling unfulfilled. ‘It feels as if marriage and children have consumed everything else I ever was. I’m not sure what’s left.’ And she’s frustrated that Rob won’t try to attract more affluent patients so they can purchase a larger house.

Stella’s brother Alex and his wife Luisa long for a baby but, frustatingly, so far Luisa has failed to conceive. Stella’s sister Corran is in a relationship that must remain secret and whose discovery would bring disaster. She also harbours an ambition to be a novelist. Although haunted by his war experiences, Rob misses the comradeship of army life and finds little satisfaction in his current role as a doctor dealing with everyday ailments. He wants to make a difference and is searching for a way to do this.

The author has a way of really drawing you into the lives of the characters. Expect the story to take you on an emotional rollercoaster from the joy of a heartwarming second chance romance, the happiness of an unexpected reunion and the possibility of a new way of life to the ever-present reminder of unbearable loss and a tragedy that gripped a nation.

I received an advance reader copy courtesy of Allison & Busby via NetGalley.

In three words: Dramatic, emotional, compelling
Try something similar: The Infinite Air by Fiona Kidman


About the Author

Author Flora Johnston

Flora Johnston worked for over twenty years in museums and heritage interpretation, including at the National Museums of Scotland, which has greatly influenced the historical fiction she now writes. The Paris Peacemakers delved into the lives of characters picking up the pieces in the aftermath of the First World War, and their stories continue in The Endeavour of Elsie Mackay. She lives in Edinburgh.

Connect with Flora
Website | X | Instagram | Facebook | Threads | Bluesky

Book Review – The House with Nine Locks by Philip Gray #TheHousewithNineLocks

About the Book

Front cover of The House with Nine Locks by Philip Gray

In post-war Flanders, Adelais de Wolf’s family is slowly, inexplicably, falling apart: her mother evermore lost to religious devotion, her father to alcohol. But with the death of a beloved uncle, Adelais finds herself in receipt of an unexpected legacy: a shuttered house in a rundown district and its contents – contents that hold the promise of independence and wealth. All that is required is application, nerve, and a willingness to break the law.

Adelais stifles her doubts and her fortunes are transformed. But with her rise come complications: her victimless crimes may not be as victimless as she supposed. Nor has she counted on the singular fanaticism of Major de Smet of the Federal Gendarmerie, a brutal detective who never forgives and never forgets.

Caught in a dangerous game of cat and mouse, will Adelais find that her new life comes at too high a price?

Format: Hardcover (416 pages) Publisher: Harvill Secker
Publication date: 23rd January 2025 Genre: Historical Fiction, Mystery

Find The House with Nine Locks on Goodreads

Purchase The House with Nine Locks from Bookshop.org [Disclosure: If you buy books linked to our site, we may earn a commission from Bookshop.org, whose fees support independent bookshops]


My Review

I loved Philip Gray’s previous book Two Storm Wood set in the aftermath of WW1 which as well as depicting the horrors of war had elements of a thriller. This time we’re in Belgium in the years following WW2 with a story that is much more of a historical crime mystery but no less compelling.

Adelais, partially disabled by polio meaning she must wear a leg brace and use a stick, is a determined young woman. Her parents are each increasingly absorbed in their own mental turmoil for reasons she does not fully understand. Her father is neglecting his business and has turned to drink, and her mother has embraced a life of prayer and good works in an effort to seek forgiveness for some unknown sin. Only her Uncle Cornelius recognises Adelais has the necessary spirit to overcome the obstacles she faces, setting her challenges such as learning to use a handcycle. He describes them as kindred spirits and treats her as a kind of protege, seeing in her a strength of will her parents seem no longer to possess.

Adelais’s success gives her the confidence to tackle other challenges, such as learning to dance, although she also has another very particular reason for wanting to do this following a chance encounter. That encounter gives rise to a friendship and a shared dream but one which will require a huge amount of money to achieve. The property she inherits on the death of her uncle which, curiously, given its rundown state is protected by nine sturdy locks and latches, offers a means to achieve this. She sets about acquiring the skills required with the dogged determination her uncle must have hoped and planned for. It’s an activity that involves months of practice to achieve the necessary degree of perfection and, having mastered it, Adelais embarks on a criminal enterprise with the help of her friend Saskia for whom the whole thing is something of a lark. They have success beyond their wildest dreams but slowly things begin to fall apart.

Meanwhile Major de Smet of the Federal Gendarmerie is obsessed with a crime that has frustrated his efforts to solve it for years. It’s become a personal crusade, one he approaches with fanatical zeal spending hours poring over evidence he has accumulated and trying to detect patterns that will lead him to the culprit. His life in other respects has been a failure but solving this could bring him the recognition he craves. His superiors have come to think of it as a lost cause and a waste of police time but he’s determined to prove them wrong.

Although we always know more than both characters, the tension comes from Adelais never realising quite how close she becomes to being discovered and de Smet never quite realising how close he is to solving the case, or how easy it is to be distracted by prior assumptions.

By this time in the book you may have forgotten the events of the opening chapter but in a series of revelations we discover the answers to many things. It’s a brilliantly constructed bringing together of many threads in the story. But for Adelais, it sheds an entirely new – and unwelcome – light on the enterprise she has been engaged in leaving her with some difficult moral choices.

The House with Nine Locks is an enthralling historical mystery. I loved Adelais and the skilfully crafted plot kept me turning the pages, including looking out for the items that feature on the cover. (If you follow Philip on X or Bluesky, you’ll find other pictures relating to places and events in the novel.)

I received an advance review copy courtesy of Vintage via NetGalley.

In three words: Compelling, intricate, suspenseful
Try something similar: The Housekeepers by Alex Hay


About the Author

Author Philip Gray

Philip Gray studied modern history at Cambridge University, and went on to work as a journalist in Madrid, Rome and Lisbon. He has tutored in crime writing at City University in London and serves as a director at an award-winning documentary film company, specialising in science and history. He lives in London.

Connect with Philip
Website | X | Bluesky