Book Review – Words for Patty Jo by Jill Arlene Culiner

About the Book

A passion for books creates a lasting bond between teenage Patty Jo and David, but small-town prejudice and social differences doom their romance.

After a summer of reading and falling in love, David heads for university, foreign adventure, and a dazzling career; Patty Jo marries slick, over-confident Don Ried.

Yet plans can go horribly wrong. The victim of her violent husband, Patty Jo abandons her home and children to live on the streets of Toronto. David, a high-ranking executive in Paris, is dismayed by the superficiality of corporate success.

Forty years later, Patty Jo and David meet again. Both have defied society; both have fulfilled their dreams. And what if first love was the right one after all, and destiny has the last word?

Format: ebook (260 pages) Publisher: The Wild Rose Press
Publication date: 16th March 2026 Genre: Historical fiction

Find Words for Patty Jo on Goodreads

Purchase Words for Patty Jo from Amazon

My Review

Although having the story arc of a romance, Words for Patty Jo is much darker than I was expecting.

The summer love affair between David and Patty Jo has to be conducted in secrecy. David’s family wouldn’t approve of Patty Jo, the girl from the wrong side of town, and Patty Jo won’t – or can’t – disclose to David the cruel reality of her home life. Their life experiences are poles apart. This is illustrated in an excruciating scene in which Patty Jo is invited to dinner at David’s house and is completely out of her depth, patronised by his awful mother and leered at by his father.

I have to say I wasn’t entirely convinced the feelings David and Patty Jo had for each other were so all-consuming that they would have lasted a lifetime had events not intervened. David’s attraction to Patty Jo seemed quite superficial and I got the sense that for Patty Jo it was a dream rather than something rooted in reality. Although David attempts to keep the relationship going once he leaves for university, his letters remain unanswered. Sadly he cannot comprehend, as we do, the reasons for this.

With David gone, Patty Jo’s lack of self-worth leads to her marry salesman Don Ried. It’s a decision that will haunt her because, cruelly, his charming persona is just a facade. I found the descriptions of the violence inflicted on Patty Jo by Don, especially those of a sexual nature, very difficult to read although I appreciate the author was determined not to underplay the reality of abusive relationships. Heartbreakingly, when Patty Jo approaches others for help, she is rebuffed, dismissed or even blamed for not being a good enough wife, as if she has brought the violence on herself.

She takes the only option available to her but it means facing opprobrium, living on the edges of society and having to degrade herself to get through each day. The only thing that keeps her going is an ambition she’s harboured since childhood. It turns out the ability to reinvent yourself, something she has in spades, will be the key that unlocks the door.

You might be thinking at this point, what’s happening with David? The truth is I found myself way more invested in Patty Jo’s story than David’s, a testament to the author’s ability to create such a compelling character as Patty Jo. The trauma of her experiences seemed much more significant than David’s disillusionment with his highflying corporate lifestyle and succession of failed relationships. I admired him for following his heart and his conscience but it didn’t move me in the same way.

Beginning in the summer of 1967 and ending decades later, Words for Patty Jo is the moving story of two people navigating the vicissitudes of life and trying to find where they truly belong.

I received a digital review copy courtesy of the author.

In three words: Gritty, unflinching, emotional

About the Author

Writer, social critical artist, and impenitent teller of tall tales, Jill Arlene Culiner was born in New York and raised in Toronto. She has crossed much of Europe on foot, has lived in a mud house on the Hungarian Plain, in a Bavarian castle, a Turkish cave, a haunted house on the English moors, and beside a Dutch canal. She now resides in a 400-year-old former inn in a French village of no interest where, much to local dismay, she protects spiders, snakes, and weeds.

Observing people everywhere, she eavesdrops on all conversations and delights in any nasty, funny, ridiculous, sad, romantic, or boastful story. And when she can’t uncover salacious gossip, she makes it up.

She has won the Tanenbaum Non-Fiction Prize in Canadian Jewish History, the 2024 Canadian Jewish Literary Award for Memoir, was shortlisted for the Foreward Magazine Prize, and twice for the Page Turner Awards. (Photo: Author website)

Connect with Jill
Website | Instagram | X | Facebook | Bluesky

Book Review – Helm by Sarah Hall

About the Book

Helm is a ferocious, mischievous wind – a subject of folklore and wonder – who has blasted the sublime landscape of the Eden Valley since the very dawn of time.

This is Helm’s life story, formed from the chronicles of those the wind enchanted: the Neolithic tribe who tried to placate it, the Dark Age wizard priest who wanted to banish it, the Victorian steam engineer who attempted to capture it – and the farmer’s daughter who fell in love. But now Dr Selima Sutar, surrounded by measuring instruments, alone in her observation hut, fears the end is nigh.

Vital and audacious, Helm is the elemental tale of a unique life force – and of a relationship: between nature and people, neither of whom can weather life without the other.

Format: Hardcover (368 pages) Publisher: Faber & Faber
Publication date: 28th August 2025 Genre: Historical Fiction

Find Helm on Goodreads

Purchase Helm from Bookshop.org [Disclosure: If you buy books linked to our site, we may earn a commission from Bookshop.org, whose fees support independent bookshops]

My Review

Helm was shortlisted for the Winston Graham Historical Prize 2026 and is longlisted for both the Walter Scott Prize for Historical Fiction and the Climate Fiction Prize.  

The book is set in the Eden Valley in Cumbria revealing a landscape that has been shaped by the elements and by the people who’ve lived there over the centuries, leaving their mark by way of stone circles, roads, castles and railways.

Observing it all, since the dawn of time to the present day, is Helm, Britain’s only named wind. In the book Helm doesn’t just have a name, it has a voice, frequently addressing the reader directly. And it has a personality too: ferocious, mischievous, mercurial, occasionally vindictive, and a wry observer of human behaviour. It revels in its own power whilst at the same time bemoaning the fact that it often gets the blame for human mishaps, everything from headaches to flatulence. (Helm does have rather an obsession with bodily functions.) If you can’t get your head around the idea of an anthropomorphic wind, then this may not be the book for you.

The book features multiple storylines set in different historical periods ranging from Neolithic times to the present day. Through them, each of which are stylistically different, the author explores the interaction between humans and the natural world.

I’m going to focus on three storylines I particularly enjoyed. In the first a Neolithic tribe embark on the mammoth task of adding a huge monolith of red sandstone to a sacred stone circle (modelled on Long Meg and Her Daughters), enacting a vision revealed to its matriarch whilst she battled against a storm caused by Helm. Moving forward to the 13th century, a fanatical priest with a reputation for savagery, arrives in the area causing fear amongst its inhabitants. He views Helm as a demonic presence and, intent on exorcising it, undertakes a gruelling trek up the mountain from which the wind arises. And in the 1950s, a troubled, lonely young girl comes to regard Helm as a friend but this is viewed as evidence of mental disorder with tragic results.

A modern day storyline involves a scientist studying the increasing levels of microplastics in the atmosphere, something that may result in irreversible change to Helm. For me, this was the least engaging of the stories, partly because I found the character Dr Selima Sutar rather annoying and because its thriller-like tone seemed out of keeping with the theme of the book. I also thought it took up too much of the book.

Helm switches frequently between the various storylines, some of which have no neat resolution. Interspersed with these are lists – Helm’s own version of the Beaufort Scale, for example – diagrams, and descriptions of ‘trinkets’, objects that are souvenirs of Helm’s encounters with humans. Helm‘s stylistic inventiveness won’t appeal to every reader but it did, for the most part, to this one.

In three words: Imaginative, spirited, compelling
Try something similar: Villager by Tom Cox or There Are Rivers in the Sky by Elif Shafak

About the Author

Sarah Hall has twice been nominated for the Man Booker Prize and is the award-winning author of six novels and three short-story collections. Notably, she is the only author to win the BBC National Short Story Award twice – first in 2013 with ‘Mrs Fox’ and again in 2020 with ‘The Grotesques’. (Photo: Author website)

Connect with Sarah
Website | Facebook