#BookReview Two Women in Rome by Elizabeth Buchan @CorvusBooks @ReadersFirst1

Two Women in RomeAbout the Book

In the Eternal City, no secret stays hidden forever…

Lottie Archer arrives in Rome newly married and ready for change as she takes up a job as an archivist. When she discovers a valuable fifteenth-century painting, she is drawn to find out more about Nina Lawrence, the woman who left it behind, .

Nina seems to have led a rewarding and useful life, restoring Italian gardens to their full glory following the destruction of World War Two. So why did no one attend her funeral in 1978?

In exploring Nina’s past, Lottie unravels a complicated love story beset by the political turmoil of post-war Italy. And as she edges closer to understanding Nina, and the city draws her deeper into its life, she is brought up against a past which will come to shape her own future.

Format: Hardcover (368 pages)  Publisher: Corvus
Publication date: 3rd June 2021 Genre: Contemporary Fiction, Historical Fiction

Find Two Women in Rome on Goodreads

Purchase links
Bookshop.org
Disclosure: If you buy a book via the above link, I may earn a commission from Bookshop.org, whose fees support independent bookshops

Hive | Amazon UK
Links provided for convenience only, not as part of an affiliate programme


My Review

Nina’s part of the story, revealed through her journal and other papers, features a particularly turbulent time in Italy’s political history – the late 1970s – a period I’ve not seen featured in historical fiction before. Although perhaps it’s my age that makes it difficult for me to see any part of the 1970s as ‘historical’!

Regular followers of my blog will know I’m not a great fan of the narrative device of the secret journal, finding it rather artificial. However, in this case the author manages to make it work chiefly because Lottie’s role as an archivist naturally involves the perusal of previously unexamined papers. Although I still found Nina’s journal remarkably detailed (she obviously had a good memory for conversations), the motivations suggested for her having kept it were believable, albeit unwise given what the reader learns about her.

As Lottie discovers, the devious machinations of government officials and those employed by the Vatican during Nina’s time in Rome continue into the present day. As one character observes, ‘The Vatican is home to the humble, the saintly and the ambitious’. And in a country where family is everything, the power of blood ties to influence events should never be underestimated or ignored.

The similarities between the two women could make them merge into one but the author successfully ensures they exist as characters in their own right. In the case of Nina, it’s her love of botanical history and the hint of intrigue. In the case of Lottie, it’s her passion for documenting and preserving the records of past lives. As Lottie reflects at one point, ‘She had a strange feeling that Nina Lawrence was speaking directly to her’. Having said that, Lottie’s curiosity does seem to have a blind spot closer to home.

As you would expect from a novel set in Rome, food features prominently. Who can blame Lottie for being tempted by the goods displayed in a delicatessen window? ‘The jars of goats’ cheeses in oil, black olives in cream earthenware bowls and salamis hanging from ceiling hooks like stalactites.’ The atmosphere of ‘the Eternal City’ is vividly evoked and I enjoyed learning about the symbolism of Medieval religious art, especially the significance of the colours used, ‘paint ventriloquism at its most dazzling’ as it is so eloquently described.

The author’s choice of Rome as a setting – a city I’ve been fortunate enough to visit – combined with a story that encompasses art history and garden design ticked plenty of boxes for me. Add in the element of mystery and a touch of romance, and you have a book that deserves to have a wide appeal. I really enjoyed it and a return trip to Rome is definitely going on my wishlist.

I received an advance review copy courtesy of Atlantic Books and Readers First.

In three words: Emotional, atmospheric, compelling

Try something similar: The Spanish Girl by Jules Hayes

Follow this blog via Bloglovin


Elizabeth buchanAbout the Author

Elizabeth Buchan was a fiction editor at Random House before leaving to write full time. Her novels include the prize-winning Consider the Lily, international bestseller Revenge of the Middle-Aged Woman and The New Mrs Clifton.

She reviews for the Sunday Times and the Daily Mail, and has chaired the Betty Trask and Desmond Elliot literary prizes. She was a judge for the Whitbread First Novel Award and for the 2014 Costa Novel Award. (Photo credit: Publisher author page)

Connect with Elizabeth
Website | Twitter | Facebook | Goodreads

#BookReview Everyday Magic by Charlie Laidlaw

Everyday MagicAbout the Book

Carole Gunn leads an unfulfilled life and knows it. She’s married to someone who may, or may not, be in New York on business and, to make things worse, the family’s deaf cat has been run over by an electric car.

But something has been changing in Carole’s mind. She’s decided to revisit places that hold special significance for her. She wants to better understand herself, and whether the person she is now is simply an older version of the person she once was.

Instead, she’s taken on an unlikely journey to confront her past, present and future.

Format: Paperback                        Publisher: Ringwood Publishing
Publication date: 26th May 2021 Genre: Fiction

Find Everyday Magic on Goodreads

Purchase links
Publisher | Amazon UK
Links provided for convenience only, not as part of an affiliate programme


My Review

I was first introduced to the writing of Charlie Laidlaw when I read his book The Things We Learn When We’re Dead so when he contacted me to let me know he had a new book on the way I was delighted to take up his offer of a digital review copy.

As Everyday Magic opens, Carole (with an ‘e’) finds herself not so much at a crossroads in her life as at a dead end. She feels ‘tethered’ to her home and family, and rather undervalued by her husband Ray and daughter Iona. She idly wonders if they would even notice if she just disappeared – until of course they ran out of food or clean clothes. I think many of us with domestic responsibilities have had the same thought at some point!  Carole also feels in an emotional rut, the shiny sparkle of her marriage now tarnished by routine.  As she observes, her love for Ray has become an ‘assumption rather than a fact’.

Her reflections on how her life might have turned out had she made different decisions brought to mind Robert Frost’s well-known poem ‘The Road Not Taken’. Carole’s solution to her current malaise is to revisit places from her past – the Edinburgh flat she lived in as an undergraduate, the pub where she first met her husband, her childhood home. It’s much like what she did in her former career as an archaeologist trying to ‘stitch together the lives of long-dead people from fragments of artefacts’. However, before long Carole has the strange sensation that her journey into her past is being steered by forces outside her control. Might that explain the objects that keep turning up in unexpected places, or the chance meeting with a former colleague that opens up the possibility of a different future for Carole?

The book has plenty of humorous touches such as the accident involving Granny and its aftermath. (Trust me, it is funny!) Or Carole’s admiration for the husky-voiced ‘sat nav lady’ who, unlike Carole, never seems uncertain about which fork in the road to take and who, Carole imagines, enjoys a glamorous lifestyle between trips. And, like me, devoted fans of a famous seasonal work by Charles Dickens will have fun spotting the subtle allusions to characters and events in that book, a graveyard revelation being one of my favourites.

Everyday Magic is a heartwarming story about rediscovering what really matters in life and the importance of treasuring the people who mean the most to you while you can.

In three words: Intimate, insightful, engaging

Try something similar: Saving Missy by Beth Morrey

Follow this blog via Bloglovin


Charlie LaidlawAbout the Author

Charlie writes: ‘I was born in Paisley, central Scotland, which wasn’t my fault. That week, Eddie Calvert with Norrie Paramor and his Orchestra were Top of the Pops, with Oh, Mein Papa, as sung by a young German woman remembering her once-famous clown father. That gives a clue to my age, not my musical taste.  I was brought up in the west of Scotland (quite near Paisley, but thankfully not too close) and graduated from the University of Edinburgh. I still have the scroll, but it’s in Latin, so it could say anything.

I then worked briefly as a street actor, baby photographer, puppeteer and restaurant dogsbody before becoming a journalist. I started in Glasgow and ended up in London, covering news, features and politics. I interviewed motorbike ace Barry Sheene, Noel Edmonds threatened me with legal action and, because of a bureaucratic muddle, I was ordered out of Greece.  I then took a year to travel round the world, visiting 19 countries. Highlights included being threatened by a man with a gun in Dubai, being given an armed bodyguard by the PLO in Beirut (not the same person with a gun), and visiting Robert Louis Stevenson’s grave in Samoa. What I did for the rest of the year I can’t quite remember.

Surprisingly, I was approached by a government agency to work in intelligence, which just shows how shoddy government recruitment was back then. However, it turned out to be very boring and I don’t like vodka martini.  Craving excitement and adventure, I ended up as a PR consultant, which is the fate of all journalists who haven’t won a Pulitzer Prize, and I’ve still to listen to Oh, Mein Papa.

I am married with two grown-up children and live in East Lothian.’ (Photo credit: Author website)

Connect with Charlie
Website | Twitter | Facebook