Book Review – The Huntingfield Paintress by Pamela Holmes

About the Book

Front cover of The Huntingfield Paintress by Pamela Holmes

Mildred Holland revelled in the eight years she and her vicar husband William spent travelling 1840s Europe, recording beautiful artistic treasures and collecting exotic artifacts. But William’s parish in a tiny Suffolk village is a world away from her previous life.

When a longed-for baby does not arrive, she sinks into despair. What options exist for a clever, creative woman hemmed in by social expectations?

Then a chance encounter fires Mildred’s creative imagination. With courage and tenacity, she embarks on a herculean task. Defying her loving but exasperated husband, and mistrustful locals who suspect her of supernatural powers, Mildred rediscovers her passion and begins to live again . . .

Format: ebook (246 pages) Publisher: Urbane Publications (since republished by Bloodhound Books)
Publication date: 2nd May 2016 Genre: Historical Fiction

Find The Huntingfield Paintress on Goodreads

Purchase The Huntingfield Paintress from Bookshop.org [Disclosure: If you buy books linked to our site, we may earn a commission from Bookshop.org, whose fees support independent bookshops]

My Review

The book is inspired by a visit the author made to the church of St. Mary the Virgin in Huntingfield, Suffolk which is famous for its painted ceiling. What is even more remarkable is the story of the woman behind it – Mildred Holland, the Huntingfield Paintress of the book’s title.

There couldn’t be more of a contrast between the years Mildred and her husband spent travelling Europe and the life that awaits them in the small village of Huntingfield. Whilst William immerses himself in his parish duties, Mildred finds herself unable to settle into the role of Rector’s wife. Despite her best efforts, the villagers don’t seem to warm to her. They find her unconventional; the fact she walks to the village rather taking the carriage for example. She becomes the focus of village gossip, some quite vicious. Her adventurous spirit, the spirit that saw her convince her husband they should embark on a tour of Europe rather than settle straight into conventional married life, now has no outlet. ‘How could life change so utterly? How could one person cope with that difference?’

Both Mildred and William are disappointed to find the parish church in a state of disrepair requiring significant financial investment. Furthermore the plain interior, a legacy of the English Reformation, is a far cry from the lavishly decorated buildings they encountered on their travels. For William, returning the church to its former glory is about helping his parishioners to feel closer to God. For Mildred, it’s more about the aesthetic possibilities and an opportunity to immerse herself in something that will provide a distraction from her humdrum life and the disappointment that she and William are childless.

Gradually Mildred finds herself more and more involved in the renovation of the church. It means not only defying social conventions but also overcoming her own self-doubt and, increasingly, severe physical challenges. Mildred’s is an inspiring story of tenacity, independence of spirit and a determination not to be limited by society’s expectations of a woman’s role. I must mention William too. His enduring support for Mildred, his admiration for her resolve and his desire to do everything in his power to ensure her happiness were very moving.

The Huntingfield Paintress is a fascinating story, beautifully told.

You can learn more about St Mary the Virgin Church, as well as view images of the interior, here. You can also listen to a podcast about the history of the building.

In three words: Engrossing, inspiring, heartwarming
Try something similar: That Bonesetter Woman by Frances Quinn

About the Author

Author Pamela Holmes

Pamela Holmes was born in Charleston, South Carolina. At the age of eight, she moved with her family to England. After school, she lived on a Somerset commune where she became adept at milking cows and laying hedges. Then she graduated as nurse from London University and began to work as a journalist in print and TV on health topics. When her sons left home, she turned to writing. The Curious Life of Elizabeth Blackwell is her third novel.  She has also written The Huntingfield Paintress (2016) and Wyld Dreamers (2018). (Photo/bio: Author website)

Connect with Pamela
Website | X | Instagram

When Are You Reading? Challenge 2026 Sign-Up

The When Are You Reading Challenge is back for 2026, once again hosted by Sam at Taking on a World of Words. It involves reading a book set in each of twelve time periods. Determining what year a book belongs in is the decision of the participant. On the whole, the rule is to choose a year where the largest part of the action occurs or the most important event.

I’ve managed to complete the challenge for the past few years, including in 2025. Not surprising perhaps given the amount of historical fiction I read but that doesn’t mean it’s always easy to match every time period.

A provisional list for the 2026 challenge is below. I’ve deliberately tried to include books that have been in my TBR pile for a long time. Some of them even appeared in a similar post last year! Links from the title will take you to the book description on Goodreads or, once I’ve read them, to my review.

If you love historical fiction but often find yourself sticking to one or two favourite time periods, or you’re keen to read more historical fiction in 2026, why not sign up?


Pre-1200:           Agrippa by Robert Harris

1200-1499:        The Pretender by Jo Harkin

1500-1699:        Act of Oblivion by Robert Harris

1700-1799:        The Ballad of Lord Edward and Citizen Small by Neil Jordan

1800-1899:        Washington Black by Esi Edugyan

1900-1919:         The Heart Stone by Judith Barrow

1920-1939:        Shrines of Gaiety by Kate Atkinson

1940-1959:        A Private Man by Stephanie Sy-Quia

1960-1979:        Lessons in Chemistry by Bonnie Garmus

1980-1999:       The Midnight Hour by Eve Chase

2000-Present:  A Legacy of Spies by John le Carré

The Future:       The Memory of Animals by Claire Fuller