Book Review – West Heart Kill by Dann McDorman @gray_books

About the Book

Book cover of West Heart Kill by Dann McDorman

You.
Yes, you, reading this.
Get in the car.

Sit in the back – you’re joining the detective and the other guy who’s driving. They’re both in the front. Don’t think about the other guy. He’s not important.

You’re going to the West Heart clubhouse. The country club that’s so swanky it’s in the title of this book. Kill. It’s not that kind of kill. Or maybe it is, after all.

You arrive, it’s the Fourth of July weekend and look – there’s cocktails on the lawn. What’s your poison

Don’t flick forward. You just have to wait. Especially for the part when you find out what happens on page XX.

Format: Paperback (288 pages) Publisher: Raven Books
Publication date: 4th July 2024 Genre: Crime

Find West Heart Kill on Goodreads

Purchase West Heart Kill from Bookshop.org [Disclosure: If you buy books linked to our site, we may earn a commission from Bookshop.org, whose fees support independent bookshops]


My Review

You. Yes, you reading this review. How do you fancy a murder mystery where the story is frequently interrupted by a case study, a questionnaire, a definition of a term or a musing on the history of the genre? Or where the author addresses you directly, telling you what you’re thinking at any particular point. Or admits that the next few paragraphs aren’t going to be particularly interesting. Or makes a point of drawing attention to the fact the narrative has switched from first person to third person or, wait for it, to first person plural. We’re not sure, are we?

Assuming you haven’t stopped reading by now, does this all sound…
a) Clever?
b) Too clever by half?
[Choose one option only]

If you leave aside all the discursive elements, the plot is actually a fairly conventional whodunnit set in a community cut off from the outside world and generously populated with characters who have both motive and opportunity to commit a murder. It’s set in 1975 which means conveniently no internet or mobile phones. There’s even a final theatrical gathering together of all the suspects before the culprit is revealed, although perhaps you won’t be surprised that this doesn’t provide all the answers. I suspect the author was chuckling away to himself as he wrote the final paragraph. This reader had a rather different reaction.

West Heart Kill is likely to divide readers. Some will find it refreshingly original, others utterly infuriating. I was somewhere in between.

My thanks to Graeme Williams and Bloomsbury for my review copy.

In three words: Inventive, provoking, clever
Try something similar: The Appeal by Janice Hallett


About the Author

Author Dann McDorman

Dann McDorman is an Emmy-nominated TV news producer. He’s also worked as a newspaper reporter, book reviewer, and cabinetmaker.

He lives in Brooklyn with his wife and two children. West Heart Kill is his debut novel.

#WWWWednesday – 24th July 2024

WWWWednesdays

Hosted by Taking on a World of Words, this meme is all about the three Ws:

  • What are you currently reading?
  • What did you recently finish reading?
  • What do you think you’ll read next?

Why not join in too?  Leave a comment with your link at Taking on a World of Words and then go blog hopping!


Currently reading

West Heart KillWest Heart Kill by Dann McDorman (ARC, Raven Books)

You.
Yes, you, reading this.
Get in the car.

Sit in the back – you’re joining the detective and the other guy who’s driving. They’re both in the front. Don’t think about the other guy. He’s not important.

You’re going to the West Heart clubhouse. The country club that’s so swanky it’s in the title of this book. Kill. It’s not that kind of kill. Or maybe it is, after all.

You arrive, it’s the Fourth of July weekend and look – there’s cocktails on the lawn. What’s your poison?

Don’t flick forward. You just have to wait. Especially for the part when you find out what happens on page XX.

The TrapThe Trap (Alias Emma #3) by Ava Glass (eARC, Penguin via NetGalley) 

How far would you go to catch a killer?

This is the question UK agent Emma Makepeace must ask herself when she is sent to Edinburgh for the upcoming global G7 Summit.

The Russians are in town and Emma and her team know a high-profile assassination is being planned. But who is their target?

There is only one way to find out. Emma must set a trap using herself as bait.

As the most powerful leaders in the world arrive and the city becomes gridlocked, Emma knows the clock is ticking.


Recently finished

In the Garden of Sorrows by Karen Jewell (MindStir Media)

Magpie Murders by Anthony Horowitz (Orion)


What Cathy Will Read Next

Normal Rules Don't ApplyNormal Rules Don’t Apply by Kate Atkinson (Penguin)

In this first full collection since Not the End of the World, we meet a queen who makes a bargain she cannot keep; a secretary who watches over the life she has just left; a man whose luck changes when a horse speaks to him.

With clockwork intricacy, inventiveness and sharp social observation, Kate Atkinson conjures a feast for the imagination, a constantly changing multiverse in which nothing is quite as it seems . . .