Book Review – My Name is Emilia del Valle by Isabel Allende, trans. by Frances Riddle

About the Book

Emilia del Valle was always destined for great things. Abandoned at birth by her Chilean aristocrat father, Emilia comes of age in nineteenth-century San Francisco as an independent and fiercely ambitious young woman, decades ahead of her time. She will do whatever it takes to pursue her life’s passion for writing, even if it means publishing under a man’s name.

When Emilia lands a position as a journalist for the Daily Examiner, her unwavering sense of adventure – and new-found determination to survive in her own name – leads her to seize the chance to cover a brewing civil war in Chile alongside another talented reporter.

But the assignment offers Emilia more than just an opportunity to prove herself as a writer. Before long she embarks on a treacherous, life-changing journey in a homeland she never knew, to uncover the truth about her father – and herself.

Format: Hardcover (304 pages) Publisher: Bloomsbury
Publication date: 6th May 2025 Genre: Historical Fiction

Find My Name is Emilia del Valle on Goodreads

Purchase My Name is Emilia del Valle from Bookshop.org [Disclosure: If you buy books linked to our site, we may earn a commission from Bookshop.org, whose fees support independent bookshops]

My Review

My only previous experience of the work of Isabel Allende is A Long Petal of the Sea which I read back in 2022. I had been put off her books up to that point because she was known for her works of magic realism which is a genre I’ve been unable to get along with. However I really enjoyed A Long Petal of the Sea and when I saw this latest book was also a work of historical fiction I jumped at the chance to read it.

Essentially the author has created the fictional character of Emilia del Valle to enable her to explore a turbulent period of Chile’s history, namely the civil war that took place in that country in 1891 between the so-called ‘rebels’ who had the support of the Chilean Navy and supporters of the President José Manuel Balmaceda who controlled the Chilean Army.

I confess I found the early parts of the book a little slow because it’s quite a while before Emilia even arrives in Chile. However, by that time we’ve learned just what a determined young woman Emilia is, intent on pursuing a journalistic career despite the obstacles placed in her path and the sexism she experiences. ‘I recognize that it must be much easier to be a man, but I am not going to let that hold me back.’

Emilia even has to fight to have her articles published under her own name rather than a male pseudonym and the editor of the San Francisco newspaper she works for, The Daily Examiner, reluctantly agrees to send her to what is an active war zone only if accompanied by a male reporter, Eric Whelan. Even then she’s told to concentrate on producing ‘human interest’ stories rather than reporting from the front line. You won’t be surprised to learn Emilia ignores the latter instruction completely although we do get examples of her ability to describe the lives and motivations of people from every part of society in occasional transcripts of her newspaper articles.

Emilia’s journey from San Francisco to Chile is just one of the testing experiences she endures. When she arrives in Chile the reader is plunged into the complexity of the civil war with its rival factions. Whilst Whelan (whose first hand experiences we occasionally get) is embedded with the ‘rebel’ forces, Emilia uses her connections to get up close to the government side. The point where the two sides come together is where the book came alive for me. The brutality of war is really laid bare in the way the scenes of battle are described and, amazingly, Emilia finds herself right at the heart of it. ‘The deafening roar of bullets, cannon blasts, shouted orders, howls of pain, wails of dying men, the whinnying of terrified horses.’

Civil war not only divides countries, it divides people and families. Many combatants on both sides have no particular loyalty to the cause or desire to kill their fellow men and women. They often have no choice. And, as we discover, you definitely do not want to be on the losing side and experience the ruthless and bloody aftermath.

Emilia feels it is her mission to tell the stories of the ordinary men and women caught up in the conflict, in her words ‘to collect the dispersed fragments of those tales’. One of the most notable of these tales are those of the women known as ‘canteen girls’ whose task is to carry water and other supplies to men in the front line, even in the heat of battle.

Her experiences leave Emilia mentally – and physically – scarred, and wondering at mankind’s capacity for violence. ‘How is it possible that, from the dawn of their presence on earth, men have systematically set out to murder one another? What fatal madness do we carry in our soul?’ I suspect it’s a question many of us have thought about in recent times.

Emilia’s attempts to find her birth father form a secondary story line and one that makes up a less signficant element of the book than I’d envisaged from the blurb. However, it does provide the jumping-off point for the final part of the book which sees Emilia embark on an epic journey by land but first by sea. ‘Sea and more sea, short days and long nights, the sun winking out on the horizon, golden twilights, the moon gliding across the black sky, crimson sunrises, radiant noonday clarity, sepulchral clouds.’ It’s a journey that’s as much self-exploratory as geographical and gives the closing chapters a rather mystical air.

There were parts of My Name is Emilia del Valle that I found absolutely riveting and I enjoyed finding out more about the history of Chile and its culture. The author is known for creating strong female characters and Emilia is a brilliant example of this.

I received an advance reader copy courtesy of Bloomsbury via NetGalley.

In three words: Dramatic, immersive, authentic
Try something similar: The Map of Bones by Kate Mosse

About the Author

Isabel Allende, born in Peru and raised in Chile, is a novelist, feminist, and philanthropist. She is one of the most widely read authors in the world, having sold more than eighty million copies of her books across forty-two languages. She is the author of several bestselling and critically acclaimed books, including The Wind Knows My Name, Violeta, A Long Petal of the Sea, The House of the Spirits, Of Love and Shadows, Eva Luna, and Paula. In addition to her work as a writer, Isabel devotes much of her time to human rights causes. She has received fifteen honorary doctorates, been inducted into the California Hall of Fame, and received the PEN Center Lifetime Achievement Award and the Anisfield-Wolf Lifetime Achievement Award. In 2014, President Barack Obama awarded her the Presidential Medal of Freedom, the nation’s highest civilian honor, and in 2018, she received the Medal for Distinguished Contribution to American Letters from the National Book Foundation. She lives in California with her husband and dogs. 

Connect with Isabel
Website | Instagram | Facebook

Book Review – Sister Rosa’s Rebellion by Carolyn Hughes @writingcalliope

About the Book

How can you rescue what you hold most dear, when to do so you must break your vows?

1363. When Mother Angelica, the old prioress at Northwick Priory, dies, many of the nuns presume Sister Rosa – formerly Johanna de Bohun, of Meonbridge – will take her place. But Sister Evangelina, Angelica’s niece, believes the position is hers by right, and one way or another she will ensure it is.

Rosa stands aside to avoid unseemly conflict, but is devastated when she sees how the new prioress is changing from a place of humility and peace to one of indulgence and amusement, if only for the prioress and her favoured few. Rosa is terrified her beloved priory will be brought to ruin under Evangelina’s profligate and rapacious rule, but her vows of obedience make it impossible to rebel.

Meanwhile, in Meonbridge, John atte Wode, the bailiff, is also distraught by the happenings at Northwick. After years of advising the former prioress and Rosa on the management of their estates, Evangelina dismissed him, banning him from visiting Northwick again.

Yet, only months ago, he met Anabella, a young widow who fled to Northwick to escape her in-laws’ demands and threats, but is a reluctant novice nun. The attraction between John and Anabella was immediate and he hoped to encourage her to give up the priory and become his wife. But how can he possibly do that now?

Can John rescue his beloved Anabella from a future he is certain she no longer wants? And can Rosa overcome her scruples, rebel against Evangelina’s hateful regime, and return Northwick to the haven it once was?

Format: ebook (446 pages) Publisher: Riverdown Books
Publication date: 4th April 2025 Genre: Historical Fiction

Find Sister Rosa’s Rebellion on Goodreads

Purchase Sister Rosa’s Rebellion from Amazon

My Review

I’ve been a fan of the Meonbridge Chronicles ever since the first book, Fortune’s Wheel. Follow the links from the titles to read my reviews of A Woman’s Lot, De Bohun’s Destiny, Children’s Fate and Squire’s Hazard. You can think of Meonbridge as the medieval equivalent of Ambridge in the long-running BBC Radio 4 drama, The Archers. This ‘everyday story of farming folk’ is interspersed with the usual life events – births, marriages, deaths – and the goings-on that occur in a small community such as disagreements between neighbours, husbands and wives, brothers and sisters. The changing of the seasons bring challenges and from time to time events in the outside world imposes themselves. People depart for pastures new and there are occasional new arrivals. And Meonbridge is not free from crime… even murder.

Sister Rosa’s Rebellion is the sixth book in the series and, as in previous books, the author has plucked one or two characters from the large cast she created in the first book (and their descendants) to be the focus of the story. In this case, it’s Johanna de Bohun, now known as Sister Rosa since her departure from Meonbridge for Northwick Priory, and Meonbridge bailiff, John atte Wode, still a bachelor living with his aged mother.

The reason for Rosa’s flight? Well, that’s a secret burden she carries. Of a shameful act in her past and guilt at its tragic consequences. Initially, she saw cloistering herself away from the outside world in Northwick as a way to atone for her sins but over the years she’s come to appreciate the simplicity and fulfilment of religious life under the wise and gentle guidance of Mother Angelica. Now that’s all at risk, and so is her secret. Will her fellow nuns think differently about her if they discover her past?

The story moves at a gentle pace but is not without moments of drama, especially in the storyline involving John atte Wode. Along the way we learn just how stratified medieval society was with most eking out a living from the land whilst a few wield power and influence, and live a life of luxury. It’s that sense of entitlement that drives Sister Evangelina who, if not exactly an out-and-out villain, certainly puts her own interests above those of others. The story also demonstrates how life in a convent might be the only option for certain young women, such as those widowed or unable to make a favourable marriage.

I loved Rosa as a character. She has immersed herself in a life of prayer and service, and possesses a strong sense of justice. But she’s also resourceful and not averse to a little subterfuge if she believes it’s for the greater good. You can’t help rooting for her and feeling empathy with her struggles to do the right thing even if that means breaking her vows. I was glad she finds out her feelings of guilt may be misplaced and I rejoiced in her role as matchmaker.

I also enjoyed catching up with other characters and seeing how the ‘wheel of fortune’ has turned for them over the years.

Sister Rosa’s Rebellion is another excellent addition to the Meonbridge Chronicles series and we are promised that more stories about the folk of Meonbridge will follow. That’s great news.

My thanks to Carolyn Hughes for my digital review copy.

In three words: Gentle, engaging, authentic

About the Author

Carolyn Hughes has lived much of her life in Hampshire. With a first degree in Classics and English, she started working life as a computer programmer, then a very new profession. But it was technical authoring that later proved her vocation, word-smithing for many different clients, including banks, an international hotel group and medical instrument manufacturers.

Although she has written creatively for most of her adult life, it was not until her children flew the nest that writing historical fiction. She has a Masters in Creative Writing from Portsmouth University and a PhD from the University of Southampton.

Connect with Carolyn
Website | X/Twitter | Facebook | Bluesky